NQUIRER FILE PHOTO
MANILA, Philippines — Search warrants must clearly specify the area to be searched. Otherwise, it will be considered invalid, according to a recent Supreme Court ruling.
In a decision penned by Senior Associate Justice Marvic M.V.F. Leonen, the SC Second Division acquitted Lucky Enriquez of illegal possession of dangerous drugs and drug paraphernalia charges. The acquittal, cited in a statement on Friday, was due to a flawed search warrant and its improper execution.
Article continues after this advertisementREAD: SC voids search warrant for ‘Tondo 3’
FEATURED STORIES NEWSINFO Marcos drops VP Duterte, former presidents in NSC revamp NEWSINFO January 9 declared a holiday NEWSINFO House exec gets word on 4th impeach rap vs VP DuterteThis decision stemmed from a 2017 operation conducted by the Philippine Drug Enforcement Agency (PDEA), during which agents implemented a search warrant against Enriquez to look for and seize dangerous drugs and drug paraphernalia.
fun77bet slotThe address in the search warrant only stated: “Informal Settler’s Compound, NIA Road, Barangay Pinyahan, Quezon City.”
Article continues after this advertisementAccording to the SC ruling, PDEA agents, guided by an informant, entered a house where Enriquez was staying without knocking or announcing their presence.
Article continues after this advertisementThe agents also rushed through the open door, arrested Enriquez, and seized sachets containing shabu.
Article continues after this advertisementEnriquez was then convicted by the Regional Trial Court, and the Court of Appeals upheld the decision.
However, the high court reversed the ruling due to the invalidity of the search warrant.
Article continues after this advertisementIt emphasized that the Constitution requires a search warrant to specifically describe the place to be searched to prevent authorities from arbitrarily deciding where to search and whom or what to confiscate.
READ: CA upholds ruling nullifying search warrant vs red-tagged journo, unionist
The SC ruled that the description in the search warrant on Enriquez’s case was “too broad and essentially a general warrant,” which is prohibited by the Constitution.
Furthermore, the SC ruled that the search warrant was not carried out properly, as the PDEA agents did not identify themselves before entering the house where Enriquez was.
According to Rule 126, Sections 7 and 8 of the Rules of Court, government agents can only force their way in if they are denied entry.
Subscribe to our daily newsletter
The law also states that searches must be made with the lawful occupants of the house as witnesses or two residents in the same area. Enriquez was the lawful occupant of the house, but he was not able to witness the search.
The BSP said maintaining the 20 percent minimum liquidity ratio (MLR) of thrift banks is “appropriate” as this ensures that smaller lenders have enough cash to withstand potential stress events while continuing to meet the funding needs of their clients.
After raising rates at a record pace from mid-2022 to tackle surging consumer pricespera play, the ECB has begun to ease the pressure as inflation rates have fallen.
READ NEXT ‘Amihan,’ shear line will still bring rains over parts of ... PNP urged to increase presence in Pampanga amid threats to off... EDITORS' PICK NBA: Heat suspend Jimmy Butler for 7 games, seek to trade him Pia Wurtzbach regards 2024 her ‘most successful year’ as self-managed artist ASF cases slightly up by end of December 2024 - BAI Cloudy Saturday, rain showers in parts of Luzon VP Sara’s removal from NSC marks intense political conflict – Castro Judge to sentence Trump before inauguration in hush money case MOST READ Cebu mayor challenges Comelec disqualification ruling 4 best business ideas in 2025 NBA: Heat suspend Jimmy Butler for 7 games, seek to trade him Legarda urges strict implementation of new PhilHealth case rates Follow @FMangosingINQ on Twitter --> View comments
